Re-Blogging Sandman: Issue #7 Sound and the Fury

sandman-morpheus-1.jpg

 

Ok. This one is visually stunning, but the writing isn't up to scruff. I should be honest, I don't have a lot of nice things to say about this one. It was bound to happen at some point that there was an issue that disappointed me, and I'm glad to get it out of the way in Preludes and Nocturnes.

It's indicative of how clever and deep the series becomes later that I was deeply disbelieving in the fact that the characters on page 2 are nothing more than walk-ons (sadly, the Annotated Sandman confirms this). I would love if these characters reappear, or were based on historical characters.

Coming after the gross brutality in the previous issue, Gaiman's broadening of scope to the world at large feels almost unnecessary (but then I'm not reading week after week as people did when the series came out).

I do wonder, on page 3, who Gaiman refers to as their "suddenly distant God." Initially I thought it was Dream, and then I thought it was Dee, a subtle comment about humanity's need to worship something, anything in times of trouble. But in the course of my overthinking, I realized they're probably referring to God God. At which point I immediately wished they were talking about Dee instead. It's a confusing statement, because we are clearly seeing humanity give in to depravity, and depravity usually implies some sort of God-less state, so either their worship needs to be depraved, or they shouldn't be worshipping at all (unless of course they're praying to the Puritan version of God, who they love precisely because he is wicked and merciless (according to Sarah Vowell at any rate)).

CHARACTER ISSUES

It's the Dalek problem. Dee is evil because he's evil and for no other reason. This sort of made the Scooby Doo villain issue even worse for me. There could have been some cleverness or irony if John Dee's desires were more complicated in the real world, but return to their most base in the Dream World.

And as for Dream? It's disappointing to see him pretty much beg Dee for the ruby back, and he begs so PLAINTively. Dream is nothing like humble, so this doesn't feel right to me. Certainly he's desperate to get his power back, but not as desperate as he was at the beginning. And he slowly won battles through cunning and through deception and understanding of his enemies' weaknesses.

LANGUAGE ISSUES

For one thing, Morpheus uses the phrase "my soul-stuff." Really, Neil? The lord of all things written or thought in the history of the Universe, and that's the word he comes up with? No.

And for another, John Dee inexplicably descends into a torrent of British slang. Aren't all the Arkham villains true blue Americans? To some extent you can blame the manifestations of the dream world for changing his speech, but he says 'cowardy custard' before even entering the Dreaming. And even if he did suddenly fancy himself British, "spineless, spittle-arsed, poxy-pale wanker," is particularly British, slang that we wouldn't even hear in the United States.

Not to mention Dee's terrible excuses for insults: "dream-puker," and "swine-scum." Zing! And out of character. After all, what is Dee but the dark reflection of Dream? He is a creator in his own way, but he chooses to use Dream's power to create situations of infinite torment, to create thoughts of immeasurable darkness. He's definitely not clich├ęd in his villainy. So when he suddenly starts talking like a Scooby Doo villain? Doesn't really work for me (and yes, I am aware that in the old Hanna-Barbera Superfriends cartoons, he was pretty much a Scooby Doo villain).

BUT ALLS WELL THAT ENDS WELL

And we see Dream show a bit of mercy, exacting no punishment greater than sending Dee back to his jail (where Scarecrow also goes strangely British with "my sainted aunt!" (It is possible that Scarecrow is an unapologetic fan of Wodehouse, but I doubt it somehow).

NEXT UP: My hero comes to town! My hero comes to town!

This entry was posted on and is filed under , . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 . You can leave a response .

4 Responses to “ Re-Blogging Sandman: Issue #7 Sound and the Fury ”

  1. Sandman does have a lot of incidental characters, but I can't say I've ever found it irritating. We only see Daniel Bustamonte and Stefan Wasserman in issue one, but their stories need to be there to show the human tragedy resulting from Dream's imprisonment. I don't mind that I never meet Nan Fowler again - rather, I'm hugely impressed that the two panels she appears in are powerful enough to move me.

    As for the suddenly-distant god, we know that we're talking about a Christian god because these people are introduced as fundamentalists; their god is suddenly distant because they expected to be with him at Armageddon, not abandoned (as they think) on the earth.

    'Wanker' in this context certainly sounds strange. Presumably they wanted a way for Dee to call Morpheus filthy names without using any recognisable swear words. Still sounds silly though.

    If there's a real weakness here I think it's the villain who does evil for the sheer joy of it. That's usually enough to put me right off a book, but in Dee's case I don't find it such a problem. The most important feature of his character, more than his wickedness or spite, is his wretchedness. From the moment we meet him we know he is physically and psychologically ruined. He doesn't have a Machiavellian scheme for world domination, or a cunning trap for his arch-nemesis. His dreams are those of a spiteful child, of a natural weakling who wants his own turn to be the bully.

    The early scenes where Morpheus tries to persuade Dee to give back the ruby did strike me as odd, though you'll notice he never protests on behalf of the humans whose lives are being wrecked - it's the Dreaming that he's worried about. On the other hand, he knows he's talking to a maniac who probably has the power to destroy him. If he treats this nasty little mortal as an equal, it's because he's terribly afraid. I'm not sure we ever see Morpheus as vulnerable as he is in 'Sound and Fury'.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well taken!

    I wonder, in my case, if it's a personal issue that I always find story conclusions disappointing, and that biases me against them from the start.

    And also, knowing how much larger the story will become, and the trials Dream will face, it's a little difficult to respect Dee as a seriously threatening villain against the power of Morpheus, especially since Dee has been defeated repeatedly by mortals, even with the power of the materioptikon at his beck and call. Morpheus has to know that Dee has no chance once he's in the Dreaming. Home court advantage x100.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The introduction to 'The Sound of Her Wings' (and the Doll's House tpb) reminds us how just much trouble Morpheus is in when he enters the diner. He wasn't strong when he emerged from crystal prison, and trying to use the ruby weakened him severely. Even in the Dreaming, Dee could have chosen to leech all his remaining power away and leave him helpless; his mistake was to destroy the jewel, releasing its power back to its creator.
    Possibly he sees greater threats over the course of the series, but I don't think we ever see him as scared as he is here.

    I didn't mention his mercy before. Besides the restoration of his power, that must be the biggest development in this issue; maybe the whole arc.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The mercy is huge. I think this is not the first or last time we see it either.

    ReplyDelete

Powered by Blogger.